|Year : 2011 | Volume
| Issue : 4 | Page : 368-371
A rapid, sensitive and reliable diagnostic test for scrub typhus in China
Zhang Lijuan1, He Si2, Jin Yuming3, Li Liang3, Li xuemei4, Liu Lianying5, Yu Huilan1, Yu Qiang6, Chen Chuangfu7, Wang Shiwen1
1 Department of Rickettsiology, National Institute of Communicable Disease Control and Prevention, China CDC, Changping P.O. Box 5, Beijing 102206, China
2 Fujian Center for Disease Control and Prevention , Fuzhou 350001, Fujian, China
3 Hainan Center for Disease Control and Prevention , Haikou 570203, Hainan, China
4 Department of Epidemiology, Hongta District Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Yuxi 653100, Yunnan, China
5 Jiangsu Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Nanjing 210009, Jiangsu, China
6 Department of Rickettsiology, National Institute of Communicable Disease Control and Prevention, China CDC, Changping P.O. Box 5, Beijing 102206; Shihezi University, Shihezi 832003, Xinjiang, China
7 Shihezi University, Shihezi 832003, Xinjiang, China
|Date of Submission||10-Jun-2011|
|Date of Acceptance||03-Sep-2011|
|Date of Web Publication||24-Nov-2011|
Department of Rickettsiology, National Institute of Communicable Disease Control and Prevention, China CDC, Changping P.O. Box 5, Beijing 102206
Purpose: To evaluate the performances for detection of IgM and IgG antibodies to Orientia. tsutsugamushi (Ot) using a gold conjugate-based rapid diagnostic test (RDT). Materials and Methods: The RDT employing mixture recombinant 56-kDa proteins of O. tsutsugamushi and the mIFA assay was performed on 33 patients from Fujian and Yunnan province respectively and 94 positive sera (36 from Hainan province and 58 from Jiangsu province) from convalescent stages of the patients with scrub typhus respectively and 82 negative sera from healthy farmers from Anhui province and Beijing City respectively in 2009. A comparison of the RDT and mIFA assay was performed by using the c2 test and the P level of ≤0.05 was considered to be significant. Results: Among these 94 positive sera from convalescent stages of the illness and 82 sera from control farmers, the specificity of RDT was 100% for both IgM and IgG tests. In 33 cases with scrub typhus, 5 cases were positively detected earlier by RDT than by mIFA for the IgM test, and 2 cases were positive for the IgG test. The sensitivities of RDT were 93.9% and 90.9% for IgM and IgG, respectively. Considering IgM and IgG together, the sensitivity was 100%. The geometric mean titre (GMT) of IFA and the RDT assay in diluted sera from confirmed cases were 1:37 versus 1:113 respectively (P<0.001) for IgM test and 1:99 versus 1:279 respectively (P<0.016) for IgG. Conclusions: The RDT was more sensitive than the traditional IFA for the early diagnosis of scrub typhus and was particularly suitable for use in rural areas.
Keywords: Colloidal gold, Orientia tsutsugamushi, rapid diagnostic test, rapid diagnosis, scrub typhus
|How to cite this article:|
Lijuan Z, Si H, Yuming J, Liang L, xuemei L, Lianying L, Huilan Y, Qiang Y, Chuangfu C, Shiwen W. A rapid, sensitive and reliable diagnostic test for scrub typhus in China. Indian J Med Microbiol 2011;29:368-71
|How to cite this URL:|
Lijuan Z, Si H, Yuming J, Liang L, xuemei L, Lianying L, Huilan Y, Qiang Y, Chuangfu C, Shiwen W. A rapid, sensitive and reliable diagnostic test for scrub typhus in China. Indian J Med Microbiol [serial online] 2011 [cited 2014 Nov 27];29:368-71. Available from: http://www.ijmm.org/text.asp?2011/29/4/368/90166
| ~ Introduction|| |
Scrub typhus is a acute febrile rickettsial diseases caused by the pathogenic agents of Orientia tsutsugamushi (Ot) and is widely distributed in China. , Outbreaks of scrub typhus have been frequently reported in recent years. , Nearly all cases are diagnosed based on the clinical features and experimentally treated without laboratory confirmation. The golden micro-indirect fluorescence assay (mIFA) proposed by the WHO collaborator center of rickettsiae have not been popularized because of limited instruments of fluorescence microscopy. Delay in diagnosis and treatment of scrub typhus often causes multi-organ failure and an increasing in mortality. It is reported that the mortality of untreated scrub typhus is up to 35%.  A reliable and rapid diagnostic reagent is urgently needed to be developed for national wide application in China. Here, we evaluated a novel RDT for detecting specific IgM and IgG antibodies to O. tsutsugamushi from patients suffering from scrub typhus.
| ~ Materials and Methods|| |
Description and confirmation of cases
Thirty three patients were all from endemic regions of scrub typhus in China, including 20 from suburbs of Fuzhou City in 2009, the capital of Fujian province and 13 from Yuxi City, Yunnan province, in 2005.  The average age of patients was 47 year old (range from 10 to 76 years old). All cases were characterized by high fever (ranged from 38°C to 41.5°C), headaches, and weakness. Eschars were noticed on bodies and extremities of 13 patients from Yunan province [Figure 1] but no rash was observed. Twenty cases from the Fujian province were recovered by oral administration doxycycline, while 13 patients from Yunnan province were treated by oral chloramphenicol. Diagnosis of scrub typhus was confirmed by typical clinical presentation and laboratory assays including detection of IgM and IgG antibodies against O. tsutsugamushi and nested PCR targeting groEL gene of O. tsutsugamushi.  This study was approved by the Human Research Ethics Committee of Chinese Centre for disease control and prevention (China CDC).
|Figure 1: Patients of scrub typhus and eschar on their bodies, Yuxi City, Yunnan Province, in 2005|
Click here to view
Thirteen sera samples from Yunnan province and 20 sera from Fujian province were collected at acute stage of illness (2 to 10 days after onset of illness) in 2005 and 2009 respectively and they were kept at -80°C until the present study. In addition to these 33 sera, 94 positive sera samples were collected from farmers from endemic areas of the Jiangsu province and the Hainan province respectively and IgG antibodies against O. tsutsugamushi were tested by IFA and they were confirmed by a positive reaction. Eighty-two sera from blood donors were collected from healthy farmers in Guangde County (50 sera) and Mingguang County (22) of the Anhui province respectively, and 10 from Tongzhou districts of Beijing City in 2009. The 15 reference rabbit sera immunized with 12 members of order Rickettsiae (C. burnetii, R. typhi, R. heilongjiangensis, R. sibirica, R. austrilia, R. prowazekii, R. conorii, R. parkeri, B. henselae, B. quintana, E. chaffensis, A. phagocytophilum, and with another 3 non-rickettsia agents, E. coli 157, Lp1 and B. melitensis) were also included in the negative control panel, which were tested to observe if cross-reaction occurred. In addition, four reference sera consisting of Ot serotypes Karp, Kato, TH187, and TA 736 were detected by the RDT.
mIFA were performed as previously described.  Briefly, sera were serially diluted 1:10, 1:20, 1:40…. in PBS with 3% skimmed milk powder and 25 ml of the diluted serum was placed in appropriate wells of the antigen slides (prepared by culture O. tsutsugamushi serotype Karp in Vero cells in our Lab) and incubated for 60 min in a moist chamber at 37°C. After washing to remove unbound antibody, slides were reacted with FITC-conjugated goat anti-human immunoglobulin (IgM or IgG, Sigma Co.) as a secondary antibody. The stained slides again rinsed and counterstained with Evan's blue before examination using a fluorescent microscope (Nikon-E400-FL-F-A, Nikon Corporation, Japan). Samples were interpreted as reactive when clear fluorescent bacterial morphology was evident. Samples reactive as the 1:80 screening dilution were deemed positive. To detect IgM antibodies, the procedure was the same as IgG antibody test except RF-absorbent (Behring Diagnostics, Marburg, Germany Behring) was used to absorb the IgG antibodies before diluting sera. Dilutions with 1:40 or larger reaction with antigen were considered positive.
Rapid diagnostic test
RDTs employed a mixture of recombinant 56-kDa proteins from different Ot serotypes including the Karp, Kato, TA736, and TH187 strains of O. tsutsugamushi as antigen. , The RDTs were manufactured and donated by InBios International, Inc. Seattle, USA, for this study. The test procedure was briefly as following: 3 drops (120 ml) of IgM or IgG chase buffer is added to a plastic well and add 5 ml of sera to the sample pad area of the test strip, followed by placing each test strip with samples applied into individual wells containing chase buffer and read the results in 15 min. The control line (C) and test line (T) appear (purple-red band) concurrently as regarding as positive. The test is considered as negative when only the control line appears. The test is invalid if no control line appears.
Limit of detection
Twenty-five IgM positive sera and 29 IgG positive sera listed in [Table 1] were randomly selected to be further serially diluted as 1:10, 1:20, 1:40 ……., and then detected by the RDT so as to determine the lowest detection limit.
|Table 1: IgM and IgG detection of O. tsutsugamushi by IFA and RDT on cases with scrub typhus|
Click here to view
Statistical analysis was conducted using SAS software (version 9.1). Comparison of the positive rates between RDT and mIFA assays was performed by using the χ2 test and the P value level was used to determine the significance and the P value of ≤0.05 was considered significant.
| ~ Results|| |
Eighty-two control sera from healthy farmer were confirmed to be negative by IFA (titres of IgM were <1:40 and titres of IgG were <1:80). All these sera were then tested by the RDT and results showed no positive reaction. For the detection of 94 positive sera (GMT by IFA:160 (80-640) from the Jiangsu and Hainan provinces respectively, the coincidence rate between the RDT and IFA was 100%. Here we concluded that the RDT was dominantly sensitive than IFA for early diagnosis of scrub typhus.
Reference sera immunized with 12 individual members of order Rickettsiae including C. burnetii (titre of IgM and IgG by IFA: 1:160; 1:128), R. typhi (titre of IgM and IgG by IFA: 1:80; 1:512), R. heilongjiangensis (titre of IgM and IgG by IFA: 1: 1:80; 1:512), R. sibirica (titre of IgM and IgG by IFA: 1:1:80; 1:512), R. australis (titre of IgM and IgG by IFA: 1: 1:80;1:128), R. prowazekii (titre of IgM and IgG by IFA: 1: 1:80; 1:512), R. conorii (titre of IgM and IgG by IFA: 1: 1:80; 1:512), R. parkeri (titre of IgM and IgG by IFA: 1: 1:80; 1:512), B. henselae (titre of IgM and IgG by IFA:1: 1:80;1:512), B. quintana (titre of IgM and IgG by IFA: 1: 1:80; 1:512), E. chaffensis (titre of IgM and IgG by IFA: 1: 1:80; 1:512), A. phagocytophilum (titre of IgM and IgG by IFA: 1: 1:20; 1:64) and 3 non-rickettsia pathogen including E. coli 157 (titre of IgM and IgG by IFA: 1: 1:40; 1:128), Lp1 (titre of IgM and IgG by IFA: 1: 1:80; 1:512) and B. melitensis (titre of IgM and IgG by IFA: 1: 1:80;1:128) were detected as negative control and results showed no reaction was noticed. Of the 15 reference sera, no cross reaction was observed. However, the 4 reference sera immunized with O.t serotypes Karp, Kato, TH187 and TA 736 were positive.
Sera from patients
IgM and IgG antibody detection were performed on 33 sera from the acute phase of illness for scrub typhus cases and 94 sera from convalescent stage of the illness by IFA and RDT. For the 33 sera from confirmed cases, the sensitivities of testing IgM by IFA and RDT were 75.6% and 93.9% respectively (P<0.05). For IgG, the sensitivities of IFA and RDT were 87.9% and 90.9% respectively. When IgM and IgG were used together, the sensitivity of IFA and RDT were 96.9% and 100% respectively.
The results showed that the sensitivity of the RDT was significantly higher than that of IFA. The GMT of IFA and RDT were 1:37 versus 1:113 respectively (P<0.001) for the IgM test and 1:99 versus 1:279 respectively (P<0.016) for IgG.
| ~ Discussion|| |
In this study, we evaluated the performance of the RDT on 33 sera from the acute phase of illness for scrub typhus cases and 94 sera from the convalescent stage of the illness, and 82 control sera from a healthy farmer donor. The evaluation results showed that the specificity of RDT is as high as 100%, based on the 82 normal human sera and 94 positive sera. Besides the mentioned 82 normal human sera, no false positives were observed on another 12 reference sera immunized with 12 individual members of order rickettsia and 3 sera immunized with 3 individual non-rickettsia pathogens. For Ot serotype TA 736 and TH187, only weak cross reactive was observed. The results of the lowest detection limit for IgM and IgG tests showed that the RDT was more sensitive than the traditional IFA assay. Considering the combined results of IgM and IgG, the sensitivity of the RDT was excellent, 100% sensitive for testing sera from acute-phage of illness (2-10 days after the onset of illness). The average titre of IgM and IgG determined by the RDT was three times higher than that of IFA (P<0.001 for IgM and 0.016 for IgG). The higher sensitivity of RDT is suitable for the earlier diagnoses of scrub typhus during the acute phase of illness, which can avoid delayed treatment and death due to multi-organ failure.
Scrub typhus is a national-wide endemic infectious disease in rural areas of China and its diagnosis is also the biggest challenge in China. The significant advantage of the RDT is that it is consisted of several recombinant 56 kD proteins including Ot serotype Karp, Kato, TA736, and TH187, which enhance its sensitivity. Until now, there are a total of eight serotypes of Ot in the world. The major serotypes of O. tsutsugamushi in China are stain Karp, Kato, and Gilliam. A novel serotype of strain Kawasaki has been discovered in recent years.  Misdiagnoses and delay treatment of scrub typhus are frequent in rural areas of China, which generally cause multi-organ failure of patients and even death. , The traditional gold standard IFA assay could not been used in rural areas because of limited medical sources.  A rapid and reliable diagnosis method is urgently needed in China and we believe that the RDT is particularly meeting this purpose.
| ~ Acknowledgement|| |
This project was supported by the National Basic Research Program of China (973 Program) 2010CB530200 (2010CB530206) and the grants from the National Key Science and Technology Projects of China (No. 2009ZX10004-203 and 2008ZX10004-008).
| ~ References|| |
|1.||Zhang LJ, Fu XP, Fan MY. Research on rickettsia and epidemiological status of Rickettsioses in China. Trop Med Parasitol 2005;3:37-42. |
|2.||Tang JQ. Natural Focal Infectious Diseases: 1 st ed. Beijing, China: Science Publishing House;2005. p. 538-62. |
|3.||Zhang LJ, Zhang J, Xia SL, Zhang JS, Li ML, Fu XP, et al. Follow-up analysis on the epidemic strains of Orientia tsutsugamushi in the first outbreak of scrub typhus in Henan province, China. Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public Health 2007;38:1-5. |
|4.||Zhang SY, Song H, Liu Y, Li Q, Wang Y, Wu J, et al. Scrub typhus in previously unrecognized areas of endemicity in China. J Clin Microbiol 2010;48:1241-4. |
|5.||Brown GW, Robinson DM, Huxsoll DL, Ng TS, Lim KJ. Scrub typhus: A common cause of illness in indigenous populations. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 1976;70:444-8. |
|6.||Zhang LJ, Li XM, Zhang DR, Zhang JS, Di Y, Luan MC, et al. Molecular epidemic survey on co-prevalence of scrub typhus and murine typhus in Yuxi city, Yunnan province of China. Chin Med J 2007;20:1314-8. |
|7.||Luan MC, Yu DZ, Tang Li, Zhang LJ. Identification of Orientia tsutsugamushi, Spotted Fever Group and Typhus Group Rickettsia by Duplex and Nested PCR Methods. Asian Pac J Trop Med 2008;1:1-8. |
|8.||Eremeeva ME, Balayeva NM, Raoult D. Serological response of patients suffering from primary and recrudescent typhus: Comparison of complement fixation reaction, Weil-Felix test, microimmunofluorescence, and immunoblotting. Clin Diagn Lab Immunol 1994;1:318-24. |
|9.||Ching WM, Wang H, Eamsila C, Kelly DJ, Dasch GA. Expression and refolding of truncated recombinant major outer membrance protein antigen (r56) of Orientia tsutsugamushi and its use in enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays. Clin Diagn Lab Immunol 1998;5:519-26. |
|10.||Ching WM, Rowland D, Zhang Z, Bourgeois AL, Kelly D, Dasch GA, et al. Early diagnosis of scrub typhus with a rapid flow assay using recombinant major outer membrane protein antigen (r56) of Orientia tsutsugamushi. Clin Diagn Lab Immunol 2001;8:409-14. |
|11.||Fan MY. Typhus. In: Zheng G's the historical experience of preventive medicine in new China. 1 st ed. Beijing: People's Health Publishing House; 1988. p. 145-53. |
|12.||Fan MY. Rickettsial diseases. In: He LY, Xu ZB's. Tropical Medicine. 1 st ed. Beijing: People's Health Publishing House; 2004. p. 336-8. |
|13.||13. Guo HB, Wu GH, Tang JQ, Li XF, Yu MM, Zhang Y, et al. Finding out Kawasaki Serotype Rickettsia Tsutsugamushi by n ested polymerase chain reaction in China. Chin J Zoonoses 1995;2:22-4. |
|14.||Zhang LJ. The situation of surveillance, prevention and control of Rickettsioses in China. Dis surveill.2007;22:577-9. |